Walko vs Festool

Been doing some handheld routing on the Festool MFT, the results of which you’ll be able to see in the next video.  I’ve been using the Festool surface clamps for much of the operation, but have been surprised to find that over time, the Walko surface clamps (which are 2/3rds the price) are actually doing a better job! (Festool $150 pair, Walko $99 pair)

fixed-clamps-mft-sp-488030

Festool Surface Clamp

 

Walko Surface Clamp

Walko Surface Clamp

(Just did an image search for both – the top 4 images of the Walko clamp all came from Stu’s Shed!)

Granted that the Festool is probably a better design, I guess, with a longer reach, the ability to secure it to the table from underneath, and I am sure there are one or two other features over the Walko.

However there is one overriding difference.  The Festool jams when you try to release it.  The Walko doesn’t.  After a while, the Festool also doesn’t slide smoothly, whereas the Walkos I have, have been going and going for years without incident.

Looking closely at the shaft of the Festool, and it is pitted along its length, dented by the securing mechanism.  Sure, I can file these off (and already have a couple of times), but it is an inherent flaw.  The metal of the shaft of the Festool surface clamp is wrong – it is too soft.  Whereas the Walko clamp has got it just right.

Not often that something is able to out-perform Festool, but in this case, something has!

Anticipation Mounts!

The latest offering from YAS Engineering is soon to become available, with the first release candidate of their new CNC mill about to make its way into Stu’s Shed.  Only 2-3 (incredibly long) weeks to go.

YAS Engineering for those unfamiliar, produce the Torque Workcentre, the Router Master and the Slab Master.

In the meantime, here is a video produced on one of their earlier prototype CNC mills.

Minecraft anyone?

Any Minecraft fans out there?

All downloaded from Thingiverse.
Steve took FOREVER. Large, and the only nozzle I have working is 0.2mm

Tried printing multiple parts simultaneously, but each time was a complete failure. So one by one by one!

Steve: http://www.thingiverse.com/thing:522605
Creeper: http://www.thingiverse.com/thing:83942
Skeleton: http://www.thingiverse.com/thing:498342
TNT: http://www.thingiverse.com/thing:548303

IMG_2631.JPG

IMG_2630.JPG

IMG_2632.JPG

IMG_2629.JPG

IMG_2634.JPG

IMG_2633.JPG

Common Sense tip #237

If you have your dust extractor in another part of the shed, and tend to remote start it, make sure that when you remove a dust bag that you replace it straight away.

Don’t expect to remember that the bag is missing the next time you go to use it, especially if you are going to do an entire session before realising.

‘Nuf said!

Manspace Mag #14

About to hit the shelves again. Now up to issue 14. Becoming quite a collection on the bookshelf!

IMG_2628.GIF

Which means it is almost time to write the article for #15! No rest for the wicked.

Delving deeper into 3D

Been concentrating quite a bit recently on the 3D printer. It is a really interesting learning curve, although it has its fair share of frustrations!

So long as you are able to work out what goes wrong when it does, so you can learn and improve (technique, settings, components etc) then it is a valuable experience. The technology (at least the very low cost machines) is still pretty rudamentary, and needs constant massaging to get results. In saying that, successful prints are rewarding- fascinating to watch the process, and what is produceable is quite amazing.

Not sure how my ratio of success to failure is going – I’d probably be lucky for it to be 1:1, but as I refine things, that will continue to improve.

The first major problem I had to deal with was bed adhesion (and that can still rear its ugly head!) If the print dislodges from the bed, then it gets pushed around by the printer head, attaches (and melts) to the printer head, or at the very least is no longer where the printer things it should be, so the printer tries unsuccessfully to print in mid air. Great if you wanted a birds nest!

IMG_2625.JPG

The birds nest, and the dog turd. Neither were what I was aiming for.

I’ve pretty much resolved the bed adhesion (mostly). The original aluminium bed is now gone, and in its place is very flat, thick tempered glass (actually some Ikea glass shelves). A regular wipe with a gluestick is sufficient for really good bed adhesion.

Why I bought the Rigidbot (RB) kit, and not a preassembled model? So I knew how it was built, and can disassemble, fix and rebuild easily, knowing how it all goes together.

A recent example:

Printing was going pretty well, but over time it was becoming increasingly obvious that there was a leak in the filament path, allowing molten filament to escape, run over the outside of the nozzle and drip into the print.

Next, I was starting to get significant shifts during the print, which is obviously not ignorable.

IMG_2624.JPG

It got to the point that the printer jammed during the print, I’m guessing on a significant glob of plastic. Not sure what caused the shifts, but one problem at a time, and maybe the second would resolve itself.

I have a dual head, so went to upgrade the second nozzle to the correct hotend (got two types in the box, and installed the wrong ones, thus the leaks that were developing I assume).

Managed that, but then the printer would not work- gave an error about a extruder not being available. Turns out that even though I was careful, and it looked fine, the thermister was dead anyway. At the same time on the working head, one of the wires pulled out from the connector for the heater.

There was so much solidified plastic ooze, nothing could be unscrewed- not the thermister, not the heater, nozzle, even the retaining bolt.

IMG_2621.JPG

Step 1
Tested the thermister by unplugging it. Got the same error (which just going offscreen said mintemp) (the thermister allows the printer controller to determine printer head temp. Normally around 200C for PLA plastic)

Tested again, but this time shorting out the two pins. Same error, but this time max temp. Ok, pretty sure the problem is the thermister.

Step 2
Reflashed the RB to make it a single extruder unit. That way I could fire it up enough to bring the heater online.

Step 3
While holding the heater wire in place, got the head up to 200C, and loosened the retaining bolt, and just nudged the thermister so it was a bit loose (remembering it is still providing current temp feedback on the active head)

Step 4
Turned off the RB, and while still hot, undid the thermister fully.

Step 5
Rebuilt the RB head to a single head setup using each of the still functional parts.

Fired it up, tested, and we are back and working.

So much easier having built the unit from a kit, this was a relatively easy evolution.

Lots of other lessons learned, such as what happens when the filament tangles on the reel 8 hours into a 10 hour print.

IMG_2623.JPG

Interesting though, it does show the internal fill structure that the slicer program creates. This is currently set at 10%.

IMG_2627.JPG

However, despite the myriad of failure mechanisms, there are also many successes.

IMG_2626.JPG

IMG_2614.JPG

IMG_2611.JPG

IMG_2613.JPG

IMG_2615.JPG

Next step is to rebuild the printer head with a better extruder and a better hotend. After that, well, we’ll see how the next changes work and what develops (or fails!)

A lot at this stage is printing for printing’s sake, as each one provides valuable lessons. Once that is nailed down, project design and 3D modeling will be next, as well as post printing treatment- smoothing prints with vapour baths.

Don’t worry, it won’t dominate the woodworking, but anything interesting, challenging and stimulating is going to get my attention! In the long run, it will be able to complement other shed operations.

One CNC Router Bit Set to Rule them All

Three Router Bit Sets for CNC hobbyists under a tin shed sky,
Seven for the 2D and 3D carvers to own,
Nine for signwriters destined to buy,
One for the Shed Dweller on his dark throne
In the Land of Stu’s Shed where the router bits lie.
One router bit set to rule them all, One router bit set to find them,
One router bit set to tempt them all and with the CNC mill bind them
In the Land of Stu’s Shed where the router bits lie.

ams-cnc-58-2

This is the ultimate CNC router bit collection that I’ve found in the latest router bit catalogue from Toolstoday.com and Amana Tool

58 CNC router bits in its own display cabinet, for CNC routing timber, MDF, laminate, plastic, aluminium, steel, foam, and composites.

That is a set and a half!

ams-cnc-58-group-revised

Drool!

%d bloggers like this: